2:31Can Uniform Civil Code Disadvantage Muslim Women?
Neutral laws can have unequal effects on religious minorities, affecting education, employment and social mobility.
"The law may appear equal on paper, but its impact is often experienced very differently."
If you look at it on paper, they will tell you both sides were held. But when you look at how they were held and why they were held, what charges were framed — you'll find that this person has a murder charge on them, that person has a theft charge. The legal apparatus, in that sense, qualitatively verifies and victimizes. Quantitatively it looks equal — the state looks with both eyes. The bigger difference is in whose eyes carry fear, whose don't. We used to see, whether it was Bhiwandi or Moradabad or Delhi, when a flag march happened, peace would return. When they saw the army's uniform, everyone became equal. Now, okay, a curfew would be imposed — in the morning, milk would still reach the Hindu locality, and milk would still reach the children in the Muslim locality too. It's not as if the milkman would be stopped from going. Today it isn't like that. Today, if a curfew is imposed, it's imposed on one neighborhood. That neighborhood's lanes are shut. Another neighborhood's lanes stay open. Outside, people are riding motorcycles on the road, they're roaming around, they're roaming around carrying sticks.
2:31Neutral laws can have unequal effects on religious minorities, affecting education, employment and social mobility.
2:32The Uniform Civil Code imposes a dominant majoritarian framework (the Hindutva framework) on all citizens of the country. Sania Ismailee dismantles the idea that uniformity can lead to substantive equality. The first episode of Emerging Perspectives is now live:
1:35“There has never been a discussion on why a community is so politically deprived.”
Discussion
0Readers only · Comments are reviewed by the desk before they appear
The journalism is free for everyone — create a free account to join the discussion.